Drink & Food Guides

How To Reheat Pizza In Toaster Oven

Tim Parry


Pizza is a favorite food of many people around the world. People often go to pizza stores and grab one there. However, the COVID-19 has a lot of restrictions, for example eating out is temporarily not allowed. Therefore, buying pizza at home is a great option. You do not have an oven and wonder how to reheat pizza in toaster oven for the best crispy, cheesy and meaty taste.

A toaster oven is an ideal choice for you if you wish to reheat leftover pizza. It is not only convenient and easy but also effective to maintain the taste as initial. It will re-melt cheese perfectly without burning it. Besides, it is also a suitable method if you are in a rush.

Many people think reheating pizzas by using a toaster oven is impossible. However, with our guidelines today, you may be surprised about what toaster ovens can do. The process of how to reheat pizza using a toaster oven is not that complex.

Let’s scroll down and discover the way of reheating pizza in a toaster oven. We provide you the useful information in our article:

Why The Toaster Oven Technique Works Best

Using toaster ovens to reheat pizza is the best method as it keeps the greatest taste, close as great as its original flavor. You may probably realize that pizza dough is similar to other loaves of bread, including starches that make the crust getting dry and tough.

When you set the oven to at least 300 degrees to reheat the dough, you can momentarily soften the dough. As a process of slow heat-up will put pressure on the starch crystals, creating and setting the moisture internal. This is a reason why reheating pizza by microwave is not a good method as the time of the heating process is short, not long enough to heat the pizza.

When Is A Toaster Oven Not An Ideal Option

A toaster oven is fairly small and just big enough for a plate in medium sizes. Furthermore, it operates with less power compared to a traditional kitchen oven. Therefore, you can solely reheat one piece of pizza at a time.

If you have the whole pizza left from last night and you wish to reheat them so your family can enjoy it together, we recommend you use a conventional oven. We would say you do not want to reheat every single slice individually, it will take much time and energy. And your kids may not be that patient.

Useful Tips On How To Reheat Pizza In Toaster Oven

We provide you some tips that may be helpful for you if you are a beginner on reheating pizza using a toaster oven. Let’s dive in:

  • To keep pizza from burning to a cinder, you should monitor your pizza after 3 or 5 minutes. Charring is a signal for you to turn back on the heat.
  • Not all ovens are the same, therefore, you should check out the manual to know how to reheat foods precisely.
  • You can slightly scab water on the cheese to make it get back to its gumminess. The signal of melting cheese is to prepare to feast.
  • Please be careful when you take the pizza off the toaster oven. Using mitts or tongs to remove your pizza. In case you get burned, immerse your hand under cold water for about 15 minutes. But still, be careful.
  • It is recommended to slather your pizza with fresh sauce prior to reheating. It would be more delicious.
  • To avoid the dough and topping from dropping through the rack, you can use a baking sheet.
  • Make sure to check the appropriate heat. The perfect temperature is 425 degrees (218 C).

Yes. These are some tips we think they are good for you to know. You can follow that to get the best pizza reheated.

Step By Step Guide On How To Reheat Pizza In Toaster Oven

The process of how to use a toaster oven to reheat pizzas is not that difficult with our instructions. We will provide you with a detailed guideline on reheating your leftover pizzas so that these pizza pieces can still taste crispy and cheesy as their original without confusion, so do not panic.

Even though many people think that toaster ovens are impossible to reheat pizzas, it not only can enhance your leftover pizzas but is also convenient and quick to do that. The procedure is the same method you often reheat foods, the difference here is the required temperature for leftover pizzas is 425 degrees (218 C).

There are people who claim that a pizza that is directly heated in gridiron has a better taste because the dough will not wholly interact with a sizzling dish and will remain soft. Nonetheless, be cautious when you want to reheat Neapolitan pizza. Its bottom is skinny, so it may crumble and crush if the toppings are too much and heavy.

Now, let’s look into the following step instructions on how to reheat pizza in toaster oven:

Step 1: Preheat the toaster oven

Because temperature is an important factor to decide whether you cure or kill the flavors, you have to preheat the oven in the right heat. First thing first, you start with preheating the toaster oven to 350 degrees or 180 C. Perform this correctly at the beginning. If you want to reheat other dishes together, it will require from 5 to 10 minutes for the toaster oven to achieve the right temperature.

Effortlessly choose among 3 functions which are Leftovers, Bake or Reheat and set the temperature. Several modern toaster ovens have a specific “reheat” function. They are normally programmed to style medium heat ranging from 300 to 350 degrees and reheat your food without burning them.

Step 2: Using foil paper to cover the baking tray

You should use foil paper to line the baking tray before placing sliced pizzas on. This will prevent the dough or toppings from falling through the rack. Besides, using foil also helps to maintain the moisture for the pizza, so your leftover pizzas will not be dry and hard to eat.

Using foil paper to cover the baking tray

Step 3: Place and put the pizza in the toaster oven

Check the oven and see whether it has achieved the perfect temperature or not. If you are starving, prevent putting your sliced pizza too early, because it may be reheated too long and lead to dryness. You can put the pizza on a baking tray or plate.

Thoroughly place the pizza on the hot baking tray, remember to utilize an oven mitt and put the pizza on it. Place the tray into the toaster oven for 10 minutes. You ought to keep on monitoring constantly to prevent burns and make sure it is perfectly reheated. The time may be more or less according to the size of sliced pizzas. However, the outcome will be sizzling hot and crispy.

Pizzas with thin bottoms normally need about 4 minutes while thick dough pizzas may require 5 to 7 minutes to be totally warm. You ought to reheat about 4 sliced pizzas one time. If you stack them, they can stick together. That may cause a big mess if the tray is overfull.

Place and put the pizza in the toaster oven

Step 4: Reheating the pizza

Now, you should leave your leftover pizzas for 5 to 7 minutes in the toaster oven, relying on the thickness of the pizzas. A great thing about toaster ovens is that they allow you to see inside. So you can check your pizzas from time to time.

When cheese begins to melt and make small bubbles, you can take them out. Keep in mind always checking for melting cheese, which will show whether they are reheated enough.

Reheating the pizza

Step 5: Taking pizzas out

When the reheating process is done, turn the toaster oven off first, then you can take your pizza out. Let’s be extremely careful as all the components of the toaster oven are awfully hot. You ought to wear gloves or kitchen towels to take pizzas out when you use a plate. Toaster ovens are narrow and small-sized, so if you accidentally touch the wall, it may quickly cause you a burn.

On the other hand, if you put pizzas on the gridiron, you should utilize a spatula or tongs to take them out. Do careful and slow movements to avoid accidents. After taking out your pizzas, you should wait for 5 minutes before eating.

Step 6: Serving

Put your pizza on a plate. You can throw fresh rucola leaves on the pizza as decoration if you want. As it is just reheated, it is still too hot to eat immediately. We would recommend you to wait a few minutes for it to cool down to avoid hurting your tongue.


After you know how to reheat pizza in a toaster oven effectively, you should know how to clean your toaster oven as well. This video will help you:

Frequently Asked Questions

[wps_accordion style=”standard”]

[wps_accordion_item title=’How Can I Store My Leftover Pizzas?’ open=’no’ icon=’arrow-circle-2′ ]

There are 2 two useful ways that you can store your pizzas to prevent any damage to your favorite foods. You can check out these methods:

  • Resealable bags or ziplock: this is the simplest way to preserve your leftover pizzas. You can stack your sliced pizzas when they have cooled down enough. That will avoid the cheese glue to the back of the other slice. Because this way will not let air through, the pizza maintains freshness and can be fresh longer.
  • Wrap and stack: if your home does not have a ziplock, the other method is to stack and wrap them. Put a sliced pizza, then cover it with a paper towel, redo it again and again with other slices. Besides, you can use a coat of wax, foil paper, and a freezer can also be an alternative for paper towels. Stack them until all slices are done in the box. Finally, wrap them in a food wrap.


[wps_accordion_item title=’How Can I Prevent The Toppings From Burning When Reheating?’ open=’no’ icon=’arrow-circle-2′ ]

You have to ensure your toaster oven is preheated. With our guidelines above on how to reheat pizza in toaster oven, you can check on the ideal temperature for preheating the device. When your toaster oven is preheated enough, you just need the pizza to be inside for some minutes.

You should place your sliced pizzas in the middle rack. Besides, you can wrap pizzas with aluminum foil which will avoid them from being brown.


[wps_accordion_item title=’Are Toaster Ovens Safe?’ open=’no’ icon=’arrow-circle-2′ ]Almost all toaster ovens are evaluated and obeyed by safety standards. Because they are an appliance with high voltage, you ought to check on it whenever you bake or reheat foods. Most injuries normally occur when users touch the hot parts while removing their foods. [/wps_accordion_item]

[wps_accordion_item title=’What Is An Ideal Temperature When Reheating Pizza In Toaster Oven?’ open=’no’ icon=’arrow-circle-2′ ]

Knowing the ideal temperature is one of the vital things on how to reheat pizza in a toaster oven efficiently. For reheating, we do not need to use a high temperature. You also need to make sure the toaster oven does not overheat. The perfect temperature is 350 degrees which is enough to reheat pizzas.

Remember to not bake pizza too slow, as it can be dry, making cheese hard and the crusts not crispy.



Sum Up

Eating leftover pizzas is not a big problem when you know how to reheat pizza in toaster oven. Now you can enjoy the leftover pizzas as newly made with crispy and gummy cheese. We would say you want to choose a way that keeps the original flavor of your pizzas. Using a toaster oven is not only convenient and quick, but it also allows you to enjoy the excellent taste of your leftover pizzas.

This is all about the method on how to reheat pizza in the toaster oven we provide you. We hope this tutorial is helpful for you to achieve the best taste of your leftover pizzas. Tell us your thoughts about this post if you found it informative.

About Author

Tim Parry

Leave a Comment